|
|  |
|
in-cites,
October 2001
Citing URL: http://www.in-cites.com/papers/Dr-Minze-Stuiver.html
|
|

 |
 |
An
essay by:
Dr. Minze Stuiver |
 |

 |
r.
Minze Stuiver, the second-most-cited scientist in the field of
Geosciences, writes about his educational experiences and some
of the highlights of his long career in Isotope Geology.
Twenty-nine of Dr. Stuiver’s papers have been cited a total
of 2,745 times to date. His most-cited paper is,
"Extended C-14 data-base and revised calib 3.0 C-14 age
calibration program," (Radiocarbon, 35[1]: 215-30, 1993),
which has been cited 1,183 times. Dr. Stuiver is Emeritus
Professor in both the Department of Geological Sciences and
the Quaternary Research Center at the University of Washington
in Seattle.
|
In addition to the standard courses,
experimental work was essential for obtaining a master's degree in
nuclear physics in the early 1950s at the University of Groningen, the
Netherlands. At the Physics Laboratorium the most illustrious faculty
member was Prof. Zernicke, the inventor of the phase-contrast
microscope. The most diversified faculty member, however, was Prof. De
Vries who, although a nuclear physicist, was branching out into
biophysics and 14C (Carbon-14 or Radiocarbon) age dating.
His interdisciplinary science approach has been a beacon ever since
and after my nuclear physics stint when I became part of the
biophysics groups and produced a Ph.D. thesis, "Biophysics of the
sense of smell." The age dating pull was stronger, however, and
subsequent work, (University of Groningen [1958- 59], Yale University
[1959-69], and the Quaternary Isotope Laboratory, University of
Washington [1969-present]) was in the field now labeled Isotope
Geochemistry.
Produced by cosmic radiation in the upper
atmosphere, 14C is cycled through the major earth carbon
reservoirs (atmosphere, biosphere, the oceans, etc.). Time is
important as 14C disappears from the scene with a half life
of 5,730 years. Comparing the initial 14C activity (which
is assumed to be identical to a 19th century level) in
plant material with remaining activity yields the radiocarbon age. The
assumption of constant initial activity leads to great torment as it
produces radiocarbon ages that are only first-order approximations of
calendar-year ages.
Samples of known age (such as tree-ring dated
wood up to 12,000 years old) are needed for the calibration
(conversion to calendar-year ages) of radiocarbon dates. Large numbers
of samples have to be measured with high precision. Counting times are
several days, and the University of Washington’s Quaternary Isotope
Laboratory data set took 30 years to develop. The combined
measurements of several laboratories are used for an internationally
accepted calibration curve which, by graphical or computerized means,
converts a radiocarbon age to a cal (calibrated) age.
Beyond the determination of radiocarbon ages,
there is an astonishing multitude of research topics that can be
investigated with the 14C isotope. This isotope greatly
facilitates the quest for scientific diversity. The interdisciplinary
nature of 14C is evident from its use. For instance, one
application is the determination of deep water residence times in the
global ocean. Another is the calculation of atmospheric carbon dioxide
residence times from releases of 20th century nuclear bomb 14C
and fossil fuel carbon dioxide (fossil fuels lack 14C). The
14C-derived history of cosmic ray flux modulation leads to
an evaluation of solar-induced climatic change, and the isotope
signals associated with the carbon transfer between atmosphere,
biosphere, and oceans yield global deforestation estimates. Techniques
used for radiocarbon dating also have evolved considerably during the
search for higher precision, greater age, and smaller sample size.
Another example is the use of the global carbon cycle in interpreting
latitude-dependent radiocarbon age offsets.
An isotope with similar applications in the
Earth Sciences is 18O (Oxygen-18). The 18O/16O
ratio of water, which depends on condensation temperature, mirrors
climate (temperature) change in ice cores over long time intervals.
The records are very detailed with transition times lasting only a few
decades between major climate changes. For GISP-2 (Greenland Ice Sheet
Project) and Taylor Dome (Antarctica) tenths of thousands isotope
ratios were measured in cores up to 3 km long. Ice is not the only
medium for this type of research, calcium carbonate in lakes (marl)
and oceans (deep sea sediment and corals) as well as tree-ring
cellulose can be used.
Work can be tedious, despite the diversity of
topics. Forty years of 14C counting with utmost precision,
day and night, year around, takes its toll. The thousands of 18O/16O
ratio measurements are easier to take because present-day mass
spectrometers are highly automated. A proper antidote is the lively
interaction with colleagues and students. And nothing beats a data set
that generates additional "earthly" knowledge.
Unfortunately, there has been a major shift over the last 40 years
away from observations towards "modelling" of existing
results. By now the pendulum has swung quite far. Observations, after
all, generate new science. For instance, the very rapid transitions
between climate modes observed in the ice core 18O record
were not predicted by modern science.
Many parameters determine the use of published
work. Quality and discipline are important. After all, there are many
more biologists than glaciologists. Crossing the boundaries between
disciplines seems to increase citation frequency. The top-cited papers
("Extended C-14 data-base and revised calib 3.0 C-14 age
calibration program," Radiocarbon, 35[1]: 215-30, 1993 and
"Comparison of oxygen-isotope records from the GISP2 and GRIP
Greenland ice cores," Nature, 366[6455]: 552-4, 9 December
1993) are used worldwide by practitioners of Archaeology, Geology,
Oceanography, Botany, Atmospheric Sciences, and Glaciology.
Scientific careers do not last very
long on the radiocarbon time scale. The finite duration has resulted
in my transfer to emeritus status. My research activities have
declined substantially since 1998 but our computerized CALIB
calibration program, fully updated by P.J. and R. Reimer of the
University of Belfast, is alive and well. The CALIB program, as well
as 14C and 18O data sets of the Quaternary
Isotope Laboratory, can be downloaded from the Web sites: http://depts.washington.edu/quil/
and http://www.calib.org.
Dr. Minze Stuiver
University of Washington
Department of Geological Sciences & Quaternary Research Center
Seattle, WA, USA
|
|
|
in-cites, October 2001
http://www.in-cites.com/papers/Dr-Minze-Stuiver.html
|
|