Beginning in mid-February 2008, the 1997-2007 online version of the Science Watch® newsletter, ESI-Topics.com, and in-cites.com, will all be featured together on the redesigned ScienceWatch.com. All previous content from the three sites will be permanently archived, and remain accessible from any existing bookmarks to the archived pages. No new content will be added to this site. Updates and new content (updated biweekly) are available at ScienceWatch.com now.
The Thomson Corporation inin-cites logoites
ScientistsPapersInstitutionsJournalsCountriesH O M ERSS feeds


S E A R C H
incites



SCIENTISTS

Scientists
Papers
Institutions
Journals
Countries
 

The Top 10...
Analysis of...
Site Map by Fields
Overview Menu of all Interviews
Podcasts
Hot Papers published within the last 2 years
Current Classics
SCI-BYTES - What's New in Research
What's New in Research

in-cites, October and 2007
Citing URL: http://www.in-cites.com/scientists/TimButler.html

Scientists
             
An interview with:
Professor Tim Butler
           
According to a recent analysis of Essential Science Indicators data, Professor Tim Butler’s work has entered the top 1% in the field of Social Sciences. Professor Butler’s current record in this field includes 10 papers cited a total of 140 times to date. At present, he is the Head of the department of Geography at King’s College, London. In the interview below, we talk with Professor Butler about his highly cited work on gentrification.

in-cites  Please tell us a little about your research and educational background.

I studied Sociology at the University of Essex in the late 1960s, graduating in 1971. Then—as now—Essex was a leading place to study social science, and I became interested in social class. I went back a few years later on a part-time basis to do an MA in Social History whilst teaching sociology at the North East London Polytechnic (subsequently the University of East London) where I worked from 1974 to 2003.

“I am increasingly interested in the intersection between class mobility, education, ethnicity, and international migration and how it is playing out in the current remaking of much of London.”

 

Like many teaching in the ex-Polytechnics, it took me some years to become interested in undertaking research as these were essentially teaching institutions based around passing on scholarship to students from backgrounds where there was not a tradition of higher education. Much more time was devoted to teaching than in traditional universities—and students benefited from this greater contact time.

in-cites  A great many of your highly cited papers deal with gentrification. What interested you in this particular line of research?

I became interested in gentrification living in Hackney in the 1970s. This was an area in which it was difficult to buy houses because the building societies generally "red lined" it, i.e., they didn’t lend on the housing in what were seen as unsuitable areas. If they were prepared to lend, it was with many restrictions such as withholding part of the loan until essential repairs were undertaken.

I observed, however, that increasing numbers of young middle-class graduates were choosing to live in the area rather than more established areas. I began to research this in the early 1980s by undertaking a Ph.D. at the Geography Department at the Open University. I was fortunate enough to be supervised by Professors Chris Hamnett and Doreen Massey, who were both interested in the processes of industrial and residential restructuring that were occurring at the time.

in-cites  Your most-cited paper in our database is the 2001 Urban Studies article, "Social capital, gentrification and neighbourhood change in London: a comparison of three south London neighborhoods" (Butler T and Robson G, 38[12]: 2145-62, November 2001). Would you please walk our readers through this paper—what were your goals, what did you find, etc.?

This paper was co-authored (like many others at the time) with Garry Robson and came out of the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC)-funded project I had as part of the Cities Cohesion and Competition program. As part of this research we investigated six areas of inner London that had been undergoing gentrification. This paper was written as we were completing fieldwork and was based on our research in three south London districts (Telegraph Hill, Brixton, and Wandsworth) which were all quite different. We were interested in the way in which social capital was often used in relation to working-class communities and asked the question about how it entered into processes of middle-class community building.

We were also interested in the different ways in which the concept was used and we contrasted the Coleman/Puttnam approach with that of Bourdieu, who argued for economic, cultural, and social conceptions of capital. He saw the latter as a relationship rather than a stock. We applied these concepts to our three chosen areas and argued that different kinds of capital were being deployed in the ways in which they were being gentrified. For example, much of the gentrification of Telegraph Hill depended on the deployment of social capital, and to some extent this compensated for a relative deficit in economic capital amongst respondents. In Wandsworth, by contrast, there was a superfluity, or so it seemed, of financial capital and the most likely form of deploying social capital was in eating out!

in-cites  What are the long-term expectations, if any, for the neighborhoods you have studied—both for the specific area and for society as a whole?

This is a difficult question to answer, but one of the most recent papers that I have written with my colleague Loretta Lees explores some of these questions in relation to Barnsbury in Islington, where we have both carried out research over recent years ("Super-gentrification in Barnsbury, London: globalization and gentrifying global elites at the neighbourhood level," Trans. Inst. Brit. Geogr. 31[4]: 467-87, December 2006). We argue that a new form of gentrification has emerged there in recent years as a result of the rise of super-wealthy professionals working in law and banking in the city of London. This has some interesting implications for the way in which London is developing with the emergence of super-wealthy areas in which only those working in elite professions can hope to buy houses or flats. There remain, of course, large tracts of social housing in such areas and it is an interesting question about what kinds of relations develop between the two groups. I am interested in what happens to gentrified areas as time goes on. I have called these social relations "tectonic" in so far as the different groups appear to slide past each other with little, if any, contact.

in-cites  If you are free to discuss them, please tell us about your current projects.

I am currently working on a project on gentrification and education in East London with Chris Hamnett, and we are looking at the overarching importance of education to many middle-class families. Interesting points to emerge from this research included the increasing importance of the buy-to-let market in housing and how gentrification is no longer restricted to the owner-occupied sector. In addition, much of the competition for housing and school places is now between sections of the middle class, and in this area ethnicity is an important consideration. Much work on gentrification has ignored the question of ethnicity but in East London the black and minority ethnic groups are rapidly establishing a middle-class presence. I am increasingly interested in the intersection between class mobility, education, ethnicity, and international migration and how it is playing out in the current remaking of much of London.End

Professor Tim Butler
Kings College London
London, United Kingdom

Professor Tim Butler's most-cited paper with 41 cites to date:
Butler T and Robson G, "Social capital, gentrification and neighbourhood change in London: a comparison of three south London neighbourhoods," Urban Studies 38(12): 2145-62, November 2001. Source: Essential Science Indicators.

in-cites, October and 2007
Citing URL: http://www.in-cites.com/scientists/TimButler.html


ScienceWatch.com - Tracking Trends and Perfomance in Basic Research
Go to the new ScienceWatch.com

Home | Search | Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Copyright
Contact Webmaster with questions/comments |
(c) 2008 The Thomson Corporation.